With today’s newspapers predicting that the Government’s 24-hour licensing acts will add millions to the cost of local community charges, Thanet North MP, Roger Gale comments:This Government's Licensing Act, which has received such wide publicity, is due for imminent implementation.
The Act has transferred licensing powers from the magistrates who had previously done the necessary job well and added the burden of responsibility to already hard-pressed local authorities. As a classic example of mending things that are not broken the transfer of duties has led to more costly bureaucracy to no perceptible advantage.
The Act has placed a further burden of cost upon, particularly, small sports and other clubs and associations that have relied upon post-match bar takings to subsidise the costs of organisation, pitch fees and the like.
And then there is the anticipated rise in the instances of "binge drinking" and associated health and social problems.
As one of the two independent and impartial members of the Speaker's panel of Chairmen who piloted this piece of legislation through its Commons Committee stage as a Bill I have respected the proper convention and have neither spoken publicly nor voted on the issue after second reading.
With the Bill now an Act, however, I feel relieved of the constraints and able to say that the Licensing Act is, arguably, one of the dumbest and most friendless of pieces of legislation that I have presided over.
This was a Bill for which there was no public clamour. I doubt whether many, if any, MPs received a single letter calling for a change in a law that was, by and large, working well and that had only been updated as recently as the 1980s. There was no mass lobby of brewers or publicans suggesting that the current restrictions upon drinking alcohol were seriously damaging trade and employment and the authorities - most particularly the police - opposed the measures. The machine, though, blundered on!
Back in the late 70s and early 80s Kent's seaside towns like Margate and Herne Bay, in common with all others, were plagued with the aggressive and anti-social results of "beano parties" thrown out of pubs simultaneously in early afternoon to give a whole new meaning to "fighting on the beaches". At the same time a largely responsible public, grown accustomed to continental café culture, failed to understand why it was unlawful to buy a pint of beer in a licensed public house on a hot summer's afternoon. The change to permit afternoon drinking was made, with the backing of police and local authorities, with good reason and to good effect.
What is now imminent is very different. ""24-hour" drinking is likely to exacerbate the difficulties experienced by those responsible for law enforcement and already arising from late-night alcohol abuse.
My constabulary boss, The Chief Constable of the British Transport Police (and a former senior Kent copper) has already indicated concern at likely problems and violence on late and overnight trains. He can sadly only be proved right. The greatest weapon in the policeman's armoury is not the baton, the cuffs or CS spray but sweet reason. Drunks do not, by their nature, respond to reason and we will almost certainly see a considerable increase in an already rising violent crime figure.
This Government Act is likely to end in tears: governments are never good at admitting mistakes but if the worst predictions are realised then I only hope that we will be swiftly given the chance, however difficult, to re-impose the controls that many if not most have regarded as sensible.